The reason I ask this is because many of you who follow my blog know that I have been concerned about the use of deadly force by police in situations in which a suspect did NOT have a firearm and the lack of options officers have in these situations.
According to available data, up to 1/3 of police fatal shootings involved such a situation.
While we have talked about using 40mm shoulder-fired “bean-bags,” or other soft projectiles in these situations, their availability to street officers is very limited. So why not bring back the shotgun and buckshot rounds that could be fired into an assailant’s low extremities with a less-than-fatal outcome?
Wouldn’t it be better to wound a disturbed person who is threatening you and others with a knife or club than have to take that person’s life?
Consistent with most firearms training protocols today, shooting a person multiple times “center-mass” with a firearm is almost always a fatal outcome.
So, why not the shotgun? In my days as a police officer, I was trained to shoot low using a 12 gauge shotgun with #00 buckshot. I was even trained to “skip” buckshot off the pavement into the legs of a threatening person with the intention that these acts would take-down, but most likely not kill, a threatening person who is NOT armed with a firearm (although raising the barrel of my shotgun to “center-mass” within a range of 10 yards most certainly would put any person out of commission.
I think about all the videos I have watched over the past years of officer-involved shootings and how many of them could have resulted in a suspect’s injury, but not death, if a shotgun with buckshot had been used.
Secondarily, the shotgun can be also used non-lethally as a “bayonet-like” weapon using butt-strokes, smashes and thrusts to disable a threatening individual. (Most of us who served in the military are very cognizant of the variety of ways a “long-gun” can be used in one’s defense. See HERE at 1:56 min. — the suspect lived, no shots fired!)
Is this something that needs to be discussed among police trainers, officers, and their leaders? It seems to make sense to me.
For example, here are three patterns: #00 buckshot pattern dispersal at 5, 10 and 15 yards.
Note: #00 Buckshot consists of 9 pellets in a shell case. See picture above.
Pictures of pellet spread comes from this site.
Here are some tactical articles on the subject: