Hope Springs Eternal from the Human Breast

Note: The title of this blog comes from the author Alexander Pope: “Hope springs eternal from the human breast.” I think about that quote and how I have always had hope for police in America. This morning, Paul Linnee, an officer I worked with during my Burnsville days, alerted me to a Facebook post by Justin Pletcher. Justin is a police officer in Columbia Heights, a suburb of Minneapolis. He celebrated his tenth year as a police officer the day George Floyd died at the hands of Minneapolis police officers. What Justin has to say gives me hope as it should you. It is the Justins of policing, the young men and women of today who will learn from this tragedy and lead their fellow police officers in a new direction with a new attitude about who they are and whom they serve.


Officer Justin with his young son as he celebrates his 10th year as a police officer.

“May 25th, 2020 was my 10-year anniversary of becoming a cop. In the first picture I posted, my wife is surprising me with a cake and my son is helping me blow out the candles. It was an important day for me, because – as most of you know – I’ve always wanted to be a police officer. As soon as professional hockey player and R& B singer were no longer options, there was no other choice for me.

“I went to college, joined the army, served in Kuwait/Iraq, all to be better prepared for becoming a police officer. When I moved back to Minneapolis, I was certain I would be a cop for MPD, but due to the financial crisis this wasn’t really a possibility. Not many places were hiring so I applied anywhere I could.

When Columbia Heights gave me the job, I was thrilled. Not only was I working for a diverse city, but I was literally working on the border of Minneapolis. For the next ten years I learned what it was to truly become a police officer. It wasn’t about the tickets and the arrests, it was about the partnerships you made. Don’t get me wrong, I love the action of the job but it’s not what fuels me to make this world a better place.On same day as my 10-year anniversary, officers from the Minneapolis Police Department murdered George Floyd. There’s no other way to put this; this was a murder.

I’ve watched the video so many times now, just trying to find some justification for the actions these men took, but I can assure you there are none. I watch this video and I get angry and I get sad and I clench my teeth and I hold back my tears and I ask, ‘Why!?’ I say this not only as a police officer, but as a white man in America. I understand the pain it causes me even if I don’t understand the reason for this violence. What I don’t understand is the pain and fear it must cause all people of color, especially black men.

“We live in two different worlds and no matter what I’ve done while I’ve worn this uniform, this has not changed. I may have changed moments but I have not changed the world like I thought I would.I’m not writing this to tell you, ‘I support you’ or ‘I understand.’ I do and I don’t, respectively, but that’s not the point of this post. The point of this post is to just tell you that I love you and that I’m sorry.

“I’m sorry George Floyd is dead. I’m sorry Philando Castille is dead. I’m sorry Eric Garner is dead. I’m sorry Sandra Bland is dead. I’m sorry Tamir Rice is dead. I want to tell you that I wish I was the cop who encountered them, because maybe they’d be alive today. I want to tell you that there are good police officers out there, trying to make this world a better place. I want to tell you everything I have done over the last 10 years to make people’s lives better, but I know right now none of that matters.

“Right now I just want to tell you that I’m listening.Today was my first day back since this incident occurred. Last night, as my wife and I laid in bed, I could hear the flash bangs going off at the 3rd precinct, less than a mile from my house. Today I got out of bed at the last possible second and barely made it to work on time. I was dreading putting on my uniform but I did it, because that’s what I do. I’m a police officer, in good times and bad.

“We watched the video again as a shift and every one of my officers was upset. One of my officers came up to me several hours later and told me that he had never watched the full video and now that he has, he still felt sick 6 hours later. We talked about George Floyd and his cries for help. We talked about George Floyd and his limp body. We talked about George Floyd in the past tense because police officers had suffocated his present tense. And as a shift we mourned an unnecessary death.

Officer Justin and Health Worker Calvin working together.

“My second dispatched call of the day today was a phone call. I called the number and a man named Calvin answered. Calvin said that he was a health inspector and that he would be inspecting some neighborhood homes today. Calvin said, ‘I’m a big black man with dreads,’ and he wanted to make sure that police were aware in case we got a call about him walking around the neighborhood. Calvin asked that I come out there to verify his employment so I could squash any calls before they became something bigger.

“I obliged and I apologized to him for this even being necessary, but I told him I understood. Anyway, I arrived and we exchanged pleasantries when I noticed he had an Omega Psi Phi bracelet on, which is a black fraternity known as “Q.” I told him my roommate in college was a Q, making the hand gestures, and that one of my officers now was a Q. Calvin smiled, I smiled, and all of a sudden the apprehension in the air immediately dissipated. He ended up knowing my college roommate pretty well, and we decided we would spend the next hour walking the neighborhood together.

“Calvin was about 15 years older than me, but we talked about how we both loved to travel and about our kids. We spoke about George Floyd and police brutality, and how it’s a different world for black men. We talked about the importance of getting to know people and how racism is borne of fear and ignorance. Calvin spoke and I listened. This second picture is of me and Calvin.

“At the end, we both said almost simultaneously how much we needed this today. We were both hurting and this was a small ray of light into a darkness that had covered us. We would have hugged but, being that we both believe in doctors and science, we elbow-bumped instead. We exchanged information and took this picture.

“An hour later my old college roommate texted me saying he heard I met Calvin and how happy that made him. Calvin then texted me a few hours after that saying that he believed things happened for a reason and that we would see each other again. I believe him. I’m not a religious guy and I mostly chalk things up to chance, but it really seemed that the universe was communicating today – at least to Calvin and me.

“I’m not writing this to tell you that everything is going to be okay. I honestly don’t know if it will be. I have hope, otherwise everything I’m doing would lose meaning. I’m not telling people to not be angry or to not protest. Black people should be angry. White people should be angry. I’m angry. I’m just writing this to tell you that I love you all and that I’m here to listen to you, whenever you’re ready to talk.

“If you’re black and hurt and you don’t understand policing, I’m here to listen. If you’re white and you feel lost and you don’t know how to use your voice, I’m here to listen. I’ll answer what I can, and when I can’t we’ll work together to find the answers.We need to listen to each other. We need to support each other. I’m only as good of a police officer as my community says I am.

“If my community doesn’t trust me, I need to listen. If my community fears me, I need to listen. I met Calvin today and I listened, and because of this I gained an ally and a friend. I know enough about change to know that you can’t tell people what to do, you need to listen to them and build change together.

“So please listen to me for this brief moment as I tell you this one thing: I’m here. Not for you, but with you. I am, have been, and will be a member of this team. Our team. I’m here. As both a police officer and as your friend. So speak. I’m listening.

“Love, Justin”


  1. David it sounds just like us during the late 60’s and early 70’s! Willing to try and change for the better everything that we could in policing. Then spent our professional lives doing that. Not necessarily succeeding but none the less trying.
    Just like many other police officers around this country Justin has the right stuff …the stuff we call humanism, empathy, love! WE care deeply about our profession, our communities and humanity. We work to change the things we can, the people who will listen, and save the lives we can. We never stop not even today. Justin will see a better tomorrow not because of this tragic event but because he and the many thousands of other great police officers want to see a better tomorrow for the people they serve and the communities they love. Including, Minneapolis, Ferguson, etc.
    Justin thanks for your heartfelt and deeply thoughtful contribution. Keep working and being the good man you are.


    1. Thanks, Charlie, we have both been the “arena” and have our scars. But I think we fought the good fight. We didn’t inflame the hearts and minds of everyone — but some we did. It is like the boy walking along the beach throwing landlocked starfish back into the sea… a man watches the boy and says you cannot save all those starfish, why try? And the boy replies, “Well, it makes a difference to those whom I can save!” Amen.


  2. Breaking the cycle of fear, mistrust and distrust starts with listening. And it comes from the top. Which is challenging for you with a leader whose position depends on creating fear. I applaud all the Justin’s and hope they inspire others within the force to change the culture of fear.


      1. I fear that we are losing the battle…those who will stir the pot are not of the right mind but of a mind to destroy the lives of those who don’t see their vision. We are losing the battle of righteous but seeing the reality of our times!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.