Peace Was Kept. Now Comes the Harder Work.

Thankfully, peace was kept in our city last night. Thank you to everyone who showed up and stood up.
The District Attorney’s decision may have been the right legal call under the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in Graham v. Connor. But it was not the right moral call.
That moral question now rests with Chief John Patterson. His internal review must answer one thing: was what happened to Corey Ruiz consistent with the training, the mission, and the leadership of the Madison Police Department?
Other forces will be at work as well. A civil suit is likely, and the city’s insurance carrier may well pay $3 million or more. A citizen complaint will probably go to the Police and Fire Commission, asking that the officer be charged under current department policy.
The Ruiz matter is not over. Historically, it never will be. The deaths of Paul Heenan, Ashley DiPiazza, and Tony Robinson at the hands of Madison police are still with us years later. Corey Ruiz is now one more in a long line of questionable uses of deadly force by our police.
All of this also unfolds during a contentious spring mayoral race, in which the mayor’s relationship to the chief of police is itself a live question. Will the new mayor order these necessary changes if the police chief hesitates?
But the focus belongs on Chief Patterson. Even if he finds that the shooting was within department policy, he can take the bold step I have long argued for. He can say: we can do better. He can set tighter rules, intensified training and higher expectations for the use of force. He can commit the department to a future where these tragedies are few and far between.
As a new chief, he can set a goal for the organization in which officers are no longer expected to use deadly force.
That action would protect citizens who make mistakes from losing their lives, and it would protect our officers from moral injury that can result in family dysfunction, drug abuse and even suicide.
That is how Madison can once again be a national leader in policing.
I have said my piece. You know where I stand. Please stand with me, and ask this department, with its diverse and highly educated officers, to become the organization it is capable of being.
— David C. Couper, Chief of Police, Madison (1972–1993)
